Skip to content

Photo: StockSnap / Pixabay

Labels04 MIN·17.11

Pay Within Sixty Days: The Minimum Decency Labels Keep Failing

Independent labels sell themselves on community and taste. Too many also pay artists late, vaguely or not at all. It’s time the scene treated accounting as an artistic responsibility.

Selected by Kwesi Donkor-Hoffmeier

Ask a dozen electronic producers about their favourite label and you’ll hear about the sound, the artwork, the feeling of belonging to a family. Ask the same dozen how long it took their last royalty statement to arrive and the room goes quiet. One says fourteen months. Another says never. A third laughs and admits she once received a payment in the form of forty free copies of her own record.

This is the dirty secret of independent dance music: the sector that prides itself on being the alternative to the majors has, in many cases, reproduced their worst habits with fewer lawyers and less shame.

The problem isn’t villainy

Let’s be fair. Most underpaying labels aren’t scamming anyone. They’re run by one or two people with day jobs, a spreadsheet and a loan from a relative. Pressing plants want deposits upfront. Distributors pay on 90-day terms, sometimes longer, and take returns months afterward. A label owner who owes an artist 800 euros while waiting on 2,000 from a distributor is not pocketing the difference. They’re just broke, disorganised and embarrassed.

But explanation isn’t excuse. The artist waiting for that 800 euros may have a rent date. And the pattern is corrosive in a different way: it teaches producers that being paid is a favour rather than a right, and that asking about money is bad manners.

What the numbers say

A survey of 214 electronic artists circulated this autumn by the Northern Producers’ Forum, a Manchester-based advocacy group, found that 58 per cent had waited more than six months for at least one statement from a label. Nearly a third had never received a full account of sales for a release. Only 19 per cent said they’d been paid within two months of the end of a sales period.

“We weren’t surprised,” says the forum’s coordinator, Prudence Ndukwe-Twigg. “What surprised us was how many people said they wouldn’t complain, because they loved the label. That’s the trap. Affection becomes a reason for silence.”

A sixty-day standard

There’s a simple fix, and it doesn’t require legislation. Labels should adopt a public commitment: statements and payment within 60 days of the close of each quarter, in plain language, with unit counts, formats and territories visible. If the money isn’t there, say so, and set out when it will be.

This isn’t radical. It’s what any small shop does for its suppliers. And it carries benefits for the label too. A clear rhythm forces cash-flow discipline. It discourages the dangerous habit of using this quarter’s artist money to cover last quarter’s pressing bill. It makes the label easier to trust and therefore easier to sign for.

THE DROP · From the crate: The Eight-Hour Mix: Why Marathon Sets Are Quietly Taking Over Streaming · Photo: Gigxels / Pixabay

“Affection becomes a reason for silence. That’s the trap.”

What a decent label does

The good ones are not hard to describe. They share a few habits:

  • A written agreement before release, in language the artist understands, covering splits, term and reversion of rights.
  • A fixed statement calendar, sent even when the figure is zero.
  • Direct access to sales data, or at least a digest of it.
  • Early, honest conversation when cash is tight, rather than silence.

Several small outfits already operate this way. A Utrecht imprint called Marrowline emails statements on the fifteenth of the second month after every quarter, with a one-page breakdown. Its founder, Dieuwke Zwaan-Bellido, says the habit saved the label. “The first time I sent a statement showing we owed an artist 63 euros, I was mortified,” she says. “Then they replied thanking me for being straightforward and sent the next record to us. The honesty was cheaper than the marketing.”

From the crate: Six Months With the Raknes DM-4: A Mixer That Argues With You · Photo: Pexels / Pixabay

The excuse of scale

The usual defence is that tiny labels can’t afford accountants or software. That was arguable ten years ago. Today, royalty tools aimed at small catalogues cost from 15 to 40 euros a month. A spreadsheet template and a calendar reminder cost nothing at all. What labels lack isn’t capacity. It’s the cultural expectation that this is part of the job.

That expectation has to come from somewhere. Artists can help by asking before signing: how often will I be paid, and can I see the last statement? Distributors can help by shortening terms for small labels with clean records. Press and platforms can help by treating payment practice as a legitimate subject of coverage, rather than backstage gossip to whisper about at the bar.

And labels themselves can decide that taste is not the only thing they’re curating. A great catalogue built on unpaid artists is a nice-looking debt.

Call it the sixty-day pledge. Put it on the website. Meet it, or explain publicly why not. Dance music has always claimed to be about people over profit. This is how that claim gets tested, one statement at a time.

Taggedroyaltiesindependent labelsopinion
Pass it on
The selector
Kwesi Donkor-Hoffmeier
Gear & Production Editor

Kwesi reviews studio and DJ hardware and explains production techniques, drawing on years as a mix engineer and sound-design tutor. He is based in Manchester.

Every track by Kwesi →

Conversation (…)

Be civil. Comments are public.

    Mixed into

    Pay Within Sixty Days: The Minimum Decency Labels Keep Failing | Sidechain