Skip to content

Photo: OrnaW / Pixabay

Festivals04 MIN·17.11

Stop Booking the Same Forty DJs: A Festival Lineup Is Not a Playlist

Scroll the posters for next summer and you will find the same names on repeat. The homogeneity is a business decision dressed as taste, and it’s making festivals worse for everyone but the agents.

Selected by Kwesi Donkor-Hoffmeier

I counted. Last week I opened the announced lineups for 26 European electronic festivals scheduled for summer 2027 and made a list of every act that appeared on more than six of them. The list had 41 names. Forty-one artists, give or take, who between them will fill roughly a third of all headline and near-headline slots across the continent.

This is not a conspiracy. It is something much duller and more damaging: an industry optimising itself into a corner.

How the squeeze works

The logic is straightforward. Festival costs have risen sharply, with insurance, stage hire, security and fuel all up. A promoter needs a lineup that sells tickets before anyone has heard a note, in the winter, when most buyers decide. The safest way to do that is to book names the audience already recognises.

Agencies understand this perfectly. A handful of them represent most of the in-demand names, and they bundle. An agent will happily offer a promoter a ‘package’: you want the Saturday headliner, so you will also take these three acts from the roster. The promoter agrees, because the headliner is non-negotiable, and the lineup fills with whoever came attached.

Then there are exclusivity radii. A big act will often demand that the festival be the only one to book them within, say, 500 kilometres and a few months either side. It sounds like a minor detail. In a crowded calendar, it means promoters compete for the same few dozen people and agree not to book anyone else of similar stature. The effect is a kind of artificial scarcity at the top, with desperate overpaying to match.

A festival that books what everyone else books has no argument for why you should go to it.

What is lost

The obvious casualty is discovery. Festivals used to be where you stumbled on something: an unknown at 2pm in a tent, a local act on a small stage whose set turned out to be the best of the weekend. When the lineup is a greatest-hits list, the smaller stages fill up with the same names too, scheduled earlier or in smaller tents, and the sense of surprise drains away.

The second casualty is identity. A festival used to mean something. You went to one for its particular sound, its odd corner of the continent, its curators’ obsessions. A festival that books what everyone else books has no argument for why you should go to it rather than the one 300 kilometres away. It competes only on price and weather.

THE DROP · From the crate: The Eight-Hour Mix: Why Marathon Sets Are Quietly Taking Over Streaming · Photo: Gigxels / Pixabay

The third casualty is the local scene, and this is the one that should embarrass the industry. When a festival in, say, Hungary or Portugal books the same international headliners as every other, it leaves out the interesting people on its own doorstep. Those artists are cheaper, closer and often better suited to the site. They don’t need flights or a rider with imported sparkling water.

The counterargument, honestly

Promoters will tell you I’m being naive, and they have a point. A risky lineup can sink a year. The tickets sold in winter pay for the summer, and a promoter who gambles on unknowns may not be around to book the following year. I have sympathy. I have watched good festivals fold.

But the data from the few who’ve tried the other way is encouraging. A mid-sized site in northern Spain, which I’ll leave unnamed because its organisers asked me not to inflate the story, shifted last year to a lineup with just two internationally known headliners and 70 per cent regional or emerging acts. Ticket sales dipped 9 per cent on the previous year. Bar spend rose, complaints fell, and re-booking for the following year, which is the metric that actually matters, went up by a fifth.

From the crate: Six Months With the Raknes DM-4: A Mixer That Argues With You · Photo: Pexels / Pixabay

What would change it

There are practical steps, and none requires heroism:

  • Promoters could refuse package deals and publish the principle openly
  • Festivals could cap exclusivity radii at a sensible figure, and negotiate it collectively
  • Local-act quotas, even a modest 40 per cent, would force a more imaginative booking process
  • Ticketing could shift later, with a second release after the full lineup is out

The last one is the hardest, because it asks audiences to trust the festival before they know what they’re getting. But trust is precisely what’s missing, and precisely what a festival should be able to earn.

The fan’s part is simple. Buy a ticket for a festival because of its curation, not its poster. Go to the small stage at 2pm. Tell your friends who you saw. Forty-one names is not a scene. It is a shortlist, and we have the right to ask for more.

Taggedlineupsbookingopinion
Pass it on
The selector
Kwesi Donkor-Hoffmeier
Gear & Production Editor

Kwesi reviews studio and DJ hardware and explains production techniques, drawing on years as a mix engineer and sound-design tutor. He is based in Manchester.

Every track by Kwesi →

Conversation (…)

Be civil. Comments are public.

    Mixed into

    Stop Booking the Same Forty DJs: A Festival Lineup Is Not a Playlist | Sidechain